Precinct A to Vote on Alcohol Sales in Pickerington Village

April 16, 2025
By Rachel Scofield

The City of Pickerington is asking residents of Precinct A to head to the polls on Tuesday, May 6, to vote on three alcohol-related issues that could pave the way for new restaurants and increased revitalization in the Olde Village.

While beer is currently allowed in Precinct A, wine and spirituous liquor sales were banned decades ago—well before the area began seeing its recent commercial resurgence. The May 6th ballot initiative includes three separate issues: one to allow the sale of wine and mixed beverages, another to allow spirituous liquor by the glass, and a third to permit Sunday sales.

If passed, these changes would remove the need for restaurants to apply for individual ballot initiatives, which are currently required to serve wine and spirits in Precinct A. Instead, the entire precinct would be designated as “wet” by the State of Ohio, streamlining the process for future businesses.

Why Now?

The initiative arrives as Local Cantina, a popular Ohio-based restaurant group, prepares to open a location at 4 E. Columbus Street. Their lease for the city-owned building is contingent on the passage of the ballot issues. City officials and community leaders say bringing Local Cantina to the heart of downtown would be a major win for both residents and current business owners.

“Having another food and drink option will bring more people downtown,” said Dave Gulden, the City’s Development Director. “It supports our mission to make the Olde Village a vibrant destination.”

If the ballot issues pass, Local Cantina will move into the old gas station at the corner of Center and Columbus Streets.

Local Cantina would join existing downtown eateries like Combustion Brewery and Bob’s Backyard BBQ, helping to create a more robust and walkable dining district.

A Boost for Business

According to the City, allowing wine and liquor sales makes Olde Village businesses more competitive with other commercial areas in Pickerington, where alcohol sales are already permitted. It also removes a major barrier for potential restaurant tenants, many of whom rely on liquor sales as a key revenue stream.

The Pickerington Area Chamber of Commerce and the Pickerington Village Association have both endorsed the measure, citing its potential to drive more foot traffic and community engagement.

Where and When to Vote

Election Day: Tuesday, May 6
Polling Location: Peace Church, Diley Road
Early Voting Began: Tuesday, April 8
Location: Fairfield County Board of Elections
Address: 951 Liberty Drive, Lancaster

Endorsed by City Leadership

Mayor Lee Gray and all the City Council members sent letters to the residents of Precinct A, encouraging a “yes” vote on all three issues, emphasizing that the move is about progress, not changing the community’s values.