April 28
5:26 a.m. Police responded to Leasure Drive, where thieves had broken windows to gain access to 17 vehicles. Officers also recovered a car that had been stolen from Columbus.
8:57 p.m. Officers euthanized a severely injured deer on Hill Road near Opportunity Way.
April 29
7:48 a.m. A City of Pickerington employee found a deer suffering from injuries and called officers to end its suffering.
10:36 a.m. Officers charged a 29-year-old Blacklick man with theft after he attempted to take a Ninja Slushie maker from Kohl’s without paying.
May 1
10:41 a.m. A 59-year-old Pickerington man reported someone used his identity to access his mother’s bank account and steal more than $8,500.
3:22 p.m. A 57-year-old Pickerington man reported that someone attempted to use his identity to purchase vehicles.
3:53 p.m. Police issued a “No Trespass” order to a 14-year-old Columbus boy who caused a disturbance at the Pickerington Library Main Branch and refused to leave.
8:17 p.m. Ulta Beauty employees reported that a man took multiple perfume testers. The suspect, a 39-year-old man from Louisville, Kentucky, had already left when officers arrived.
May 3
10:31 a.m. A 15-year-old Pickerington girl reported that a 16-year-old Pickerington boy threatened to shoot her with an airsoft gun.
Pickerington Police April 20-26, 2026