One Weekend Remains to Catch for this Powerful Performance

November 13, 2026
By Rachel Scofield
There is still time to experience the story of Come From Away at Wagnalls Community Theatre, where a cast of 17 Central Ohio performers is bringing the remarkable true story of a small Newfoundland town and the thousands of strangers it welcomed to life.
With the production entering its final weekend, tickets remain available for Friday, Nov. 13, and Saturday, Nov. 14. The Sunday, Nov. 15, matinee is sold out.
Based on events that unfolded following the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11, 2001, Come From Away tells the story of the people of Gander, Newfoundland, and the nearly 7,000 airline passengers who were forced to land there when U.S. airspace closed.
Through the experiences of both the local residents and the stranded travelers, the musical explores the fear, confusion and uncertainty of those days, as well as the extraordinary kindness that emerged when strangers opened their homes and hearts to people in need.
Some characters and stories combine the experiences of multiple people, while others are based on actual individuals, including American Airlines Capt. Beverly Bass, the airline’s first female captain; Kevin Tuerff and Kevin Jung, a couple traveling from Los Angeles; and Nick and Diane, two people who met in Gander.
The musical, written by Irene Sankoff and David Hein, features more than 100 characters portrayed by a relatively small company of performers. At Wagnalls, that company is larger than usual — and intentionally so.

A story about bringing people together
Chris Hughes said the decision to stage Come From Away was influenced both by the 25th anniversary of the events it depicts and by the musical’s message of community.
“We chose this show because 2026 marked the 25th anniversary, but we also chose it because of the community aspect of people coming together, strangers supporting strangers,” Hughes said. “They welcomed people into their homes, their churches, their schools – literally let them take over and made comfortable at all times.”
That message is one of the reasons the musical resonates with audiences. At its heart, it is a story about ordinary people responding to extraordinary circumstances by looking beyond their own lives to help others.
For director Matthew DeCarlo-Boyd, the show was a personal favorite long before he took on the challenge of directing it. After 25 years of performing, Come From Away marks his directorial debut.
“I fell in love with this show the first moment that I heard it,” he said.
His husband had traveled to New York and encouraged him to listen to the musical.
“He was like, ‘You’re going to love this show, it’s amazing, you got to listen to it.’ I gave it a listen and was hooked immediately.”
DeCarlo-Boyd was drawn to the music as much as the story.
“The soundtrack tells the story, such a beautiful, beautiful story. Some of the music is lighthearted and it’s got this little folksy feel, which I’ve always just been drawn to.”
His hope is that audiences take home more than an appreciation for the performers and music.
“I think people will leave here feeling there is hope for a better tomorrow,” he said.

The ensemble is the star
One of the distinctive things about Come From Away is its ensemble cast.
“The nice thing is that there is not a single star,” Hughes said. “You go to see Legally Blonde and there is Elle Woods, but in Come From Away you have all the different characters, and none of them are the true lead — the lead is the ensemble.”
That philosophy influenced the casting process.
DeCarlo-Boyd said that actors from all over Central Ohio responded enthusiastically to auditions, with at least 50 people coming out for the opportunity to participate.
“The greater Columbus area showed up for sure,” he said. “At least 50 – for here in Lithopolis, that is huge. Most people don’t even live around here. Some come from as far as the other side of 270 to do this show. It is just that impactful that they wanted to be part of it.”
The traditional production uses 12 performers, but DeCarlo-Boyd and the production team expanded the Wagnalls cast to 17.
“We expanded it to 17 because the talent was so good ,” he said.
The show is a complicated undertaking. Each performer portrays multiple characters, requiring quick transitions and careful coordination among the cast.
“One person does one thing and it affects five other people, but then each person plays multiple roles, too,” DeCarlo-Boyd explained.
With more than 100 characters represented by 17 actors, performers must create distinct personalities and boundaries between their various roles. Some characters are loud and outspoken, while others are quiet and gentle.
DeCarlo-Boyd described the opportunity to portray so many different people in one production as an actor’s dream but the theme of the show was also a draw.

“There are individuals in this show that needed this show more than the show needs them — they were looking for an outlet, looking for a community.”
He also said the casting process was about more than finding performers who could handle the demanding roles. The production team wanted to ensure the cast reflected the diversity of the people represented in the story.
“We, as a production team, wanted to make sure that this was not a whitewashed version, and we wanted to make sure that we had somebody onstage that every audience member could identify with,” he said.
Hughes said the team also wanted to remain faithful to the original musical.
“We also wanted it to be authentic to the original because a lot of the characters are a combination of actual real people, and we wanted to be true to the actual script,” he said.
The music is part of the Ensemble, too
The production’s ensemble extends beyond the actors to include the musicians performing the score live.
DeCarlo-Boyd said the production team felt strongly that prerecorded music tracks would not adequately serve the show.
“The ensemble, inclusive of the band. The band is something that, as a production team, we felt so strong about. We couldn’t utilize tracks. We needed to do this show correctly.”
The team launched a GoFundMe campaign to help pay for the live musicians. DeCarlo-Boyd personally committed to covering whatever costs remained beyond what the fundraiser raised.
“It was that important to the show, and watching it last night, it was breathtaking,” he said. “I’m getting chills just talking about it.”
The live music is another example of the commitment behind the production and the importance of every person contributing to the finished performance.
Finding a place to belong
The performance lasts an hour and 40 minutes with no intermission.
“There is no natural place written in there, and you could not cut this show up because it is such a build of emotions,” he said.
Final performances
Wagnalls Community Theatre’s production of Come From Away concludes this weekend.
Remaining performances are:
- Friday, Nov. 13, at 7:30 p.m.
- Saturday, Nov. 14, at 7:30 p.m.
The Sunday, Nov. 15, matinee at 2 p.m. is sold out.
The performance runs approximately 1 hour, 40 minutes, without an intermission.
Tickets are $17 for adults and $15 for students and senior citizens. Tickets can be purchased online HERE.
Wagnalls Memorial is located at 150 E. Columbus St. in Lithopolis.
Theatergoers can also enjoy special offers from two local businesses. Show your performance ticket or playbill at The Pump House to receive 10% off your order, or at El Pedregal to receive 20% off your order.
Following Come From Away, Wagnalls Community Theatre’s next production will be The Dining Room, scheduled for the weekends of April 16 and 23, 2027.
For those who have not yet seen Come From Away, there are still two opportunities to experience a production built around a simple but powerful idea: Sometimes the most extraordinary things happen when ordinary people open their doors to strangers.





