
September 21
4:59 p.m. Police cited a 46-year-old Mount Gilead man for failing to maintain his lane on Hill Road and causing an accident involving two other vehicles.
September 22
12:31 p.m. An Ulta Beauty employee reported that a 26-year-old Columbus woman who had allegedly shoplifted fragrances from the store on Sept. 20 had returned and stolen additional merchandise. The woman had left the store and entered Five Below.
When officers questioned her, the woman explained that she had taken face towels valued at $17.99 because her skin had broken out and “gas prices were high.” She offered to pay for the towels, but Ulta employees declined, saying the store intended to file charges for both that day’s incident and the earlier theft.
When asked about the Sept. 20 incident, the woman disputed the store’s calculations. She allegedly said the cologne was worth only about $100 and smelled bad.
The woman asked whether she would be arrested, explaining that she had only a few weeks remaining on her parole from Trumbull County. However, officers discovered that she was also wanted on felony charges out of Licking County. The warrant instructed officers to consider her “armed and dangerous.”
The woman was arrested and charged with theft. She was subsequently transferred to the Licking County Sheriff’s Office on the felony warrant. She was also trespassed from Ulta Beauty. A 26-year-old Canal Winchester woman was separately trespassed from the business.
September 23
9:16 a.m. Lawn equipment fell from a landscaping truck onto Hill Road near Stonecreek Drive.
11:39 a.m. Fairfield County Adult Protective Services alerted police to concerns involving a 47-year-old woman who had allegedly worn a wig while using a bank drive-thru to withdraw more than $15,000 from her elderly mother’s account. The mother told officers that her daughter had cancer and that treatment had cost more than $50,000. The daughter had permission to withdraw money from the account.
September 24
11:17 a.m. A charcoal grill ignited a porch in the Melrose neighborhood.
12:27 p.m. The driver of a Revit box truck traveling northbound on Hill Road swerved left of center and sideswiped a Mazda CX-9 before leaving the scene.
September 25
10:59 a.m. A trash worker discovered a 2-year-old boy wandering along a street in the Windmiller neighborhood. The toddler, who could not speak, was wearing only a filthy shirt and a bulging, leaking diaper. After searching for approximately 30 minutes, the worker encountered the boy’s 22-year-old sister, who said the boy had sneaked outside while their 4-year-old sister was getting the mail.
1:44 p.m. A Willow Pond resident reported that someone had taken her wallet from her unlocked vehicle during the night.
September 26
12:47 a.m. Police arrested a 40-year-old Crooksville woman on felony drug charges after a K9 unit alerted officers during a traffic stop.
3:42 p.m. Police cited a 31-year-old Columbus man for speeding on Columbus Street near Alyssa Drive and driving without a license.
5:30 p.m. An unknown man allegedly caused a disturbance at Speedway and assaulted a teenage employee.
September 27
2:58 p.m. A Reynoldsburg woman reported that she had accidentally left her phone and wallet in a shopping cart at Five Below and someone had stolen them.
Pickerington Police Reports – September 14-20, 2026





